Saturday, 6 August 2011

a field student of progress


As Field Study’s Man in E17, I have lost myself this week in ‘Heritageshire’ in the hope of finding the true paradise. I have walked and cycled the corridors of internal (or could I say infernal?) combustion and in this progress I have sought relief from the heat of these rivers of road rage in the cool, slow, deep swims of the River Great Ouse. Here my progress is delivered under the similitude of a dream, wherein is discovered the manner of my letting out, my dangerous journey and safe arrival at the desired town of Bedford - a pilgrim to a pilgrim.

I joined 'Christian' for a walk to the feet of John Bunyan - a monument dating back to 1873.


This journey has for some been one of many trials and much tribulation, particularly for the pedestrian where paths have been closed - and dare you transgress!


I pondered the sensitivity of the modern day paths of progress; the relationships between site and safety or safe passage. Perhaps a specially commissioned bronze traffic light would be a more sympathetic and contemporary interactive element in this tribute to the author of one of the most significant works of religious literature. Here Bunyan, looking towards The Celestial City, waits to cross with the red man, known as Patience.


Wait patiently and another, more luminous green man, known as Mr Ready to Halt, will come to assist you in your progress; erring on the side of caution of course.


Fear reigns about such enchanted ground - do not idle on the highway - it is no place to dream. With the aid of Mr Ready to Halt's crutch I crossed and found myself on the threshold of a magical sphere for which there is a key or code to grant access. Sorcery?


Alas this humble pilgrim did not have a smart device with which to venture into the realms of the QR Code. Strange though, I believe I did hear via feint echoes from distant Memoryshire, the voice of Anton Rodgers, of Radio4ham, enact The Pilgrims Progress in feverish tones.

The sculptor was, Sir Joseph Edgar Boehm (1834 - 1890)





The monument was made in the foundry of N Young & Co, London.

An inscription beneath this detail reads:

It had eyes lifted up to heaven
The best of books in his hand
The law of truth was written upon his lips
It stood as if it pleaded with men.

Friday, 5 August 2011

a field student of paradise






As Field Study’s Man in E17, I am currently holidaying in paradise. Paradise, I have heard, ‘is exactly where you are right now only much much better’. I am studying how and why e.g. being in Letchworth Garden City is ‘much much better’ (paradisiacal) than being in Walthamstow. Letchworth like Walthamstow* expresses  some of the homogeneity and pressures of the modern day urban and suburban except Letchworth has a cinema. This deficiency (along with some others) on the part of Walthamstow may, for some, represent a sort of distinctiveness however, as recent demonstrations have shown, there is a popular demand for Walthamstow’s EMD Cinema to reopen and not become a place of worship for the UKCG. I believe some cinemas e.g. Stratford Picturehouse are (or have been) places of worship for congregations of various sorts. Of course many cinemas are multiplexes and so are able to host religious services while opening the other auditoria for the viewing of films. The EMD has one screen/auditorium and so there is a conflict of use and interest there.
As Field Study’s Man in E17, I have mused on the pseudo religious purpose of cinemas/cinema in previous posts and so I am again, following a visit to Letchworth Broadway Cinema, to see, Tree of Life - Terence Mallick’s cinematic hymn to the agony and ecstasy of love and the cosmos. Before bathing in the super nova of Brad Pitt, Sean Penn and other computer generated imagery I happened (by chance?) to visit, paradise; a public sculpture by Bettina Furnée, given as a gift from North Hertfordshire District Council to Letchworth Garden City on the occasion of the latter’s 100th anniversary. It was unveiled on 9th October 2003, by Cllr Howard Marshall. Just across the road from the cinema, the sculpture is a complex site or arrangement of elements which includes a set of 4 ubiquitous street signs presenting a fragmented message which, when read together, form an aphorism, ‘paradise is   a promise     as well as   a memory’. The extent or range of this sculpture come installation is open to interpretation; it remained part of my experience of ‘Tree of Life’ which began with a quote from Job 
in the English Standard Version of the bible:
.
“Where were you when I laid the foundations of the earth …….. when the morning stars sang together?”
.
Job 38, 4-7, in full, reads:

4.        Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth?
            Tell me if you have understanding
5.        Who determined its measurements - surely you know!
            or who stretched the line upon it?
6.        On what were its bases sunk,
            or who laid its cornerstone,
7.        when the morning stars sang together
            and all the sons of God shouted for joy?
           
Bettina Furnée’s temple like creation, no doubt built in collaboration with many and various agencies, is, in part, a dedication to the origins of Letchworth Garden City as envisioned by Ebenezer Howard. The cylindrical beams making up the temple are inscribed with diagrams representing the concepts of the garden city. The diagrams appear like mandalas, each an engraved circular geometry which proposes, via a constellation of 7 cities to provide homes, farms, reservoirs, asylums, waterfalls and new forests - all these founded in a radical form of social enterprise. In the scheme, ‘No.7 group of slumless smokeless cities’ there are also areas for homes for waifs and for inebriates, epileptic farms and an insane asylum. These schemata come from Ebenezer Howard's, ‘To-Morrow: A Peaceful Path to Real Reform’, which was reprinted in 1902 as, ‘Garden Cities of To-morrow’. When studying for a crafts degree I was required to study the ideas of thinkers who informed the Arts and Crafts Movement. Ebenezer Howard was, with the Garden Cities Movement, allied to William Morris in his disaffection with the modern industrial city. The garden is the fulcrum of this utopian movement.

In this Utopian vision the lives of its inhabitants will be in harmony with the omnipotent turmoil of the microcosmic and macroscomic universes in which (the mother, Mrs O’Brien (Jessica Chastain) in Tree of Life narrated) we have a choice of paths to follow, those of ‘grace’ and/or ‘nature'. Urban planning could make this choice of paths clear. Life, in Howard’s grand scheme, could also be represented by magnetic forces of attraction and repellence - via his ‘3 Magnets’ diagram (also indented in the corner posts of Furnée’s temple/house/sculpture).

THE THREE MAGNETS

THE PEOPLE
Where will they go?

Town
Closing out of nature. Social opportunity.
Isolation of crowds. Places of amusement.
Distance from work. High money wages.
High rents & prices. Chances of employment.
Excessive hours. Army of unemployed.
Fogs and droughts. Costly drainage.
Foul air. Murky sky. Well-lit streets.
Slums & gin palaces. Palatial edifices.

Country
Lack of society. Beauty of nature.
Hands out of work. Land lying idle.
Trespassers beware. Wood, meadow, forest.
Long hours, low wages. Fresh air. Low rents.
Lack of drainage. Abundance of water.
Lack of amusement. Bright sunshine.
No public spirit. Need for reform.
Crowded dwellings. Deserted villages.

Town-Country
Beauty of nature. Social opportunity.
Fields and parks of easy access.
Low rents, high wages.
Low rates, plenty to do.
Low prices, no sweating.
Field for enterprise, flow of capital.
Pure air and water, good drainage.
Bright homes & gardens, no smoke, no slums.

Freedom. Co-operation.

(source: Wikipedia)


Where were Mallick’s O’Briens? I witnessed their melodramas and psychodramas in the landscape of a 1950s American Dream. Sometimes the dreamy vision of blissful domesticity, maternity and motherhood seemed overdone and verged on parody and pastiche. All this was projected in a suburbia verging on the bucolic and pastoral - while the patriarch marched through the midst of a humongous steel constructed industrial plant.  The inevitable paternal/patriarchal dysfunction, witnessed during a dinner table scene and through the peeping eyes and trespass of young Jack, came via more subtly rendered contexts. How can this dramatic landscape be understood in terms of the Utopian ‘Town-Country’ magnet? Some of the intricacies and intimacies of their lives were, perhaps, the product of grand plans devised (‘conferenced’) in crystalline uber modernist heaven scraping towers - the contemporary likes of which we witnessed Older Jack (Penn) in, going through an existential (mid-life?) crisis. If this conjecture has some sort of vacuous abhorrence, then there are the interstellar forces of nature to comprehend, if not to reconcile with our (or rather my) insignificance within.     

I stepped out of the Broadway Cinema, inebriated by Mallick’s vision and felt tempted to emulate the playful pretend drunken walks of the film’s brothers. I faltered down the steps and along the pavement towards my bicycle. I looked towards ‘paradise’ and saw an ominously cast shadow towering from it, up a nearby wall. I recalled the bare ground within the space of the ‘temple’ and imagined sacrificial rites performed there, intended to appease the gods of town planning and so made haste lest I, a pilgrim to public art, should acquire sacrificial significance. 












* - this link is included as it touches on the subject of the various causes by which people move or are moved away from London to towns in the Home Counties.

Thursday, 4 August 2011

a field student of ISPs

As Field Study’s Man in E17, I do not like to think I am only because I blog. However recent on-line technical difficulties have occupied and preoccupied me to such an extent this existential state could be uncomfortably truthful, as for more than two weeks now my home broadband connection has been virtually useless due to a fault with the internet service provider’s facilities. I have been virtually incommunicado. I will not name the ‘provider’ however some small items of information - cable, up to 50MB, - might serve as clues towards identification. I have wasted a lot of time trying to clarify and resolve the various inadequacies with this service via telephone. The service provider has, in my opinion, a loathsome telephone customer service with which I have felt frustration and annoyance and to such a distracting degree I have concluded these negative qualities form the (unstated) mission of the service. My experience of the company is of incompetence in terms of their maintaining a consistent, reliable connection between ‘internet’, ‘service’ and ‘provider’.
.
A library Wifi user in exile
This post is linked to the previous post which expressed some issues about library use and proposed closures in Waltham Forest. Until February this year I used the Wifi at Walthamstow Central Library 3, sometimes 4, times a week. I was increasingly dissatisfied with the quality of the Wifi connection there and other difficulties using the library, especially the reference library. The other difficulties included not being able to get a seat, conduct of other users regarding food, drink, music, mobile phones, attitude of some to library staff and other library users. An aggressive threatening response to a polite request to a neighbour to turn their music volume down, followed by a refusal by a member of staff to act on the disruptive behaviour lead me to a broadband (and other media) shop on Selborne Walk - a decision I regret immensely. I have continued to visit the library though not for the internet.
.
How low can this ISP go?
I subscribed to a 50MB broadband connection, costing £35 a month. The subscription is based on a one year contract and incurred an additional installation fee. Within minutes of the first installation engineer leaving, the broadband connection was faulty. Following hours of calls and incorrect technical advice, more engineers were eventually booked to visit. New hubs/cables were installed. There was some improvement for a brief period only for the connection to fail again. Again, hours were spent on the phone attempting to negotiate dates for engineers to visit and financial recompense for the virtually non-existent broadband connection. The initial installation was made in February and it was April before something like the ‘up to 50MB’ service was established. I am aware 50 MB is rarely what is provided and what can be expected is something between 35-45MB when the service is working well. If there is peculiarly high usage in the service area (area 22 in this case) lower speeds can be experienced. How low can this provider justify going?
.
A case of virtual dissonance?
Several weeks later the broadband connection stopped working again. The tedious process of trying to rectify this problem ensued - again. Another engineer visited. Cables were changed. The hub was checked. The result was, amazingly, a relatively good period of broadband connection - until mid July. Yet again the service crashed. Yet again more soul destroying telephone conversations with and seemingly interminable waits for ‘customer services’ ensued. What sort of customer service is this? The ‘customer service’ is oxymoronic as far as this customer is concerned.
When I first reported the new fault I was told the problem would be resolved within 24 to 48 hours. It wasn’t. I called again. I had to wait another 3 days for an engineer to visit. The engineer checked the local junction box and diagnosed ‘the amplifier’ as being faulty - resulting in fluctuating signals. This could not, according to him, be sorted out for at least a week because there was ‘a big job on in Enfield’. One week later I was getting miniscule connection speeds of e.g. 0.02MBps. So poor was the connection it took several attempts to open the same company’s online customer service feedback form. How risible is that? Obviously with speeds like that there was no useful internet connection and mostly ‘unable to connect’ notices were the order of the day, evening, night and morning - despite being told by technical services connection speeds would improve during off peak hours. I called again and I was informed the area fault would not be resolved until the 25th October - over 3 months.
.
To Cancel a contract?
I called again, this time asking the company to call me back. I explained I had had enough and wanted to cancel the contract without a penalty fee for doing so. I explained the service to me had been lousy and unreliable from the start and I was not content to pay even a reduced charge of £15 per month for a miniscule connection speed which makes internet connection nigh on impossible. I was batted about between customer relations and technical services. Customer relations wanted to me to downgrade to a 2MB connection and pay £18.97 per month for it. In exasperation I repeated I was getting miniscule connection speeds and no useful internet connection - and technical services had said this would be so until October. How can they consider charging anything for this? The customer ‘relater’ resorted to writing an email to her manager and kept me waiting until she had completed it in order to give me a reference number. Many days later and I have not had any follow up from customer relations.
.
Consequences and implications.
The loss of the broadband connection has disrupted a variety of projects I’m involved in; some of them personal and others more community orientated. It’s likely I will return to using the library Wifi/internet service. Returning to the issues of library services, service reductions and closures, I wonder about the efficacy of participation in the public sphere via the internet - a tool for conviviality, to refer again to Charles Leadbeater and Ivan Illich. In my experience, internet use in libraries appears to be oversubscribed and is often disruptive in terms of behaviour, whilst a prominent commercial broad band provider seems (at least) unable to provide the service where I live. How, if at all, has public policy concerning library and other information services been determined by assumptions about the efficiency of commercial internet service providers? If there is to be a push for and reliance on public/political participation via the internet then the cynically exploitative ‘up to’ should not be permitted.
Here are some links to news and discussions concerning broadband provision in the UK:

.
Lessons learnt?
It might be useful to draw up a set of questions to ask when making enquiries about broadband connections, e.g.
What if the 50 Mb service (costing £35 a month) fails and reduces to 0.01 MBps for several months? Will I have to continue paying and how much?        
How long should I expect to spend on the phone to customer services trying to sort out the broadband connection problems?
How much will the calls cost me?
How long will it take for engineers to visit and should I rely on their punctuality and technical expertise?
How flexible in terms of customer convenience will you, the provider, be when making appointments?
When your facilities and services fail what do you think you are depriving or excluding your customers from? How does the Internet Service Provider take responsibility for failure to provide internet services? 

Sunday, 24 July 2011

a field student of archives, libraries and consultations

Field Study’s Man in E17 currently resides in a billet measuring 280x340x370cm. This space has an ordinary assortment of domestic furnishings including a double bed, a wardrobe, and a chest of draws, a desk and chair, several book shelves. It also accommodates his archive of art works or field studies - a relatively large collection of boxes, crates, files, books and other items. To maintain the room as a place for art activity, the archive is tightly packed, remote and less than easily accessible. Various efforts to sort out the archive, e.g. chronologically, have never been completed and the physical/geographical inaccessibility has been accompanied by a temporal or cerebral inaccessibility. The prospect of trying to retrieve an item from this awkward and confused memory is daunting and often deters the effort. The stuff(ing) is effectively lost.
So it was this evening he remembered he has/had some photographs of a ‘planning for real’ workshop in action, dating back to the mid 1990s. He was involved with a community arts organisation in Stevenage that instigated some projects about countryside access. He was thinking about ‘planning for real’ in relation to Adrian Stannard’s talk about issues and ways of increasing participation in the public planning process. If he recalls correctly his photographs show members of a community working out, by modelling, how a new road/bypass might affect their locality, including access to the surrounding countryside. He scrabbled about in the far reaches, heights and depths of his 35,224,000 cubic cm alter-cranium for the images. A landslide of a crate of slides temporarily buried him and so put an end to his search. What of this failure? Would the photographs actually reveal anything about the process which could not be communicated by other more easily accessible images? Was this another instance of Field Study’s Man in E17 aka Julian Beere attempting to qualify some sort of notion of himself - the photographs akin to art boy scout badges? Field Study’s Man in E17 could award himself a medal for bravery in action under-the-bed and dress his chest up like a field marshal on parade.

Let’s return to the serious subject of participation in public planning, policy and implementation. Planning for Real® is real and I (who?) mentioned it to AS at the NfN talk and it transpired something similar may have been tried as part of the development of a new housing estate near The Epicentre. I don’t know if Planning for Real ® was what was used in Stevenage however it seems to me that embodied approach to planning is an accessible or inclusive way of getting people involved in a consultation.

The issue of civic participation and consultation is prevalent in the mind of Field Study’s Man in E17 as he has been trying to get to grips with the prospect of library closures in Waltham Forest. The London Borough of Waltham Forest has instigated a public consultation about this and Field Study’s Man (here shifting into citizen J Beere mode) has started to fill in a form while also consulting various sources of information and opinion about the issue of library closures - many of which are on-line.
From the pages of Prospect* magazine, Charles Leadbeater refers to the personal computer, the internet and the mobile phone as vernacular tools that allow people to collaborate and communicate. He says this in relation to an assessment of Ivan Illich’s Tools for Conviviality, which asserts an ethos aimed at undermining or subverting the dominance of technocratic elites. Top down, hierarchical professional policy makers, planners, and developers are to be challenged and accompanied by the cooperative and co opted citizen. The latter is not to be just a consumer of public services but more a stake holder and budget holder. This participation will be, in part, enabled by new technology.
Users of Harrow Green Library face the prospect of that library’s closure and thus ‘free’ access to the internet. Of course the internet provision is not really free; it is just not paid for at the point of access but paid for by Council Tax and the council asserts or rather proposes there is insufficient revenue via Council Tax to fund that library and its services. Harrow Green Library internet users will have to go to other libraries where there will be longer waiting times for the pc/internet use. Harrow Green Library is in an area of relatively high social deprivation in the borough and people who use the library for study and job searching will be disadvantaged socially, culturally and economically. The most used service at Harrow Green Library is the internet. Of course, there are other options for internet access via other publicly funded means as well as commercial and private facilities. Popular access to the internet is in a state of technological flux and all sorts of ‘smart’ devices can enable connection or connectivity. The long term question concerns, how the effects of decommissioning and losing genuinely local resources can be alleviated by such things as convivial ‘apps’?
The Harrow Green Library profile, provided by the consultation states, 84% of users travel less than a mile to get to the library. This suggests a considerable change for, inconvenience to and disenfranchisement of library users in the area. Unless the council accompanies such a closure by improvements in the provision of the remaining libraries, the closures of Harrow Green and South Chingford libraries will represent a form of deterrence against library use. I think the premise of the consultation is flawed in the way it isolates libraries, identifying some as less used or successful than others, and so does not maintain a sense of the library service as a whole. Taking away some libraries is not necessarily going to benefit other libraries.


* - Charles Leadbeater, The DIY State, in, Prospect magazine, January 2007.   

Friday, 15 July 2011

a field student of cogitations




Field Study's ruminant in E17 headed for the vegetable (vegetative?) fields of E4 to seek some grounded reflections on the this, that and every which way dilettantish nature of his studies. Above he found the keenly perforating thorns of the forest garden's worcester berry bushes, the fruits of which were to be found hanging beneath the leafy canopy, hidden in a high summer forest gloom. An acidic sharp and sweet reward. 

While elsewhere on the allotment plot, below is evidence of a sustained procession around the raised rocket bed - a path trodden, scraped, plucked and stripped so as to be bare to the soil and dust. This vigorously peppery rocket appears to have found it's roots in the former site of a once long established composting site.


Tuesday, 12 July 2011

a field student of planning processes and agendas

How and why does public art come to be in Waltham Forest? A partial answer came via Adrian Stannard at this month’s News from Nowhere Club meeting and talk. Adrian Stannard asked, will the internet encourage the public to engage in the planning process in Waltham Forest? He explored the issue of participation via a series of power point slides with a guiding commentary on the many stages and implications of public planning processes.
One of the slides concerned the Section 106 Agreement. This is what developers can pay to offset negative impacts caused by their construction and development projects. Adrian Stannard spoke about Tesco and Highams Park as an example. A million pounds may be paid to the community to fund tree planting, community facilities and other needs. There is a local report about this here.
Public art happens to be one of the expenditures to which Section 106 funds can be applied. I wondered if it was Section 106 funding which helped pay for The Hitchcock Gallery at Leytonstone Tube. The basis of this might have been making public transport facilities in the area more attractive and conducive so as to offset the increase in Tesco customer motor traffic in the area - an environmental agenda. Of course, I am speculating and their funding of that public art could have been for very different reasons and Adrian Stannard certainly made no reference to specific circumstances of any commercial development and the commissioning of new public art.    
During his talk, AS was generally sceptical about the integrity of ‘Section 106 Agreements’, saying in some instances they may verge on the corrupt and are, particularly for the layman, a confused and confusing civic grey area. Stannard speculated councils may be in receipt of various funds which are directed at similar elements of the same development and so it can be difficult to tell who has paid for what. If someone has reasonable cause to doubt a particular Section 106 Agreement there is a Local Government Ombudsman to complain to.
The local government ombudsman states planning permission is conditional on the developer first (my emphasis) entering into an agreement or obligation, more commonly referred to as a ‘Section 106 Agreement’ and once signed it is a legally binding contract. Developers can make an application knowing that they too can complain to the local government ombudsman and incur costs on a council if it takes an unduly long time to draw up the Section 106 Agreement. In this respect the agreement may give the larger developers powerful leverage in the application process which can subdue or obscure smaller local contingencies and objections - even when they are actually made as a part of the ‘legitimate’ planning process.
Elsewhere, objections to supermarket developments have taken on more radical and additional direct actions and strategies - Stokescroft being a prime example. If public art was to be one of the supermarket chain’s offsets there, then the local campaign against that store and company certainly did a lot to create its own counter/contra public art. Objections to supermarkets are those which could also be made against many other global retail businesses and it could be unfair to focus on Tesco but for the fact (?) Tesco is the UK’s leading grocer so has a huge and iconic influence on the character, culture and distinctiveness of the areas in which its stores reside. I know this from, in part, the experience of working on a small market garden/farm with a farm shop whose fruit and veg’ sales declined drastically when the nearby Tesco store installed new checkouts (I think they had new weighing scales) and their queues reduced in proportion to our loss of custom. We were not alone; a new and improved (metaphorical) supermarket bull dozer had rolled into town.      
Leytonstone is a business improvement district and developing high street commerce might be one of the strategies aimed at improving the economic/cultural life of the area. What influence does this initiative have on planning processes in terms of business development? How does public art, in its many guises, influence local commerce? Having participated in the E17 Art Trail, including post event discussions and evaluations, feedback has sometimes pointed to the economic benefits of art trails as more people are attracted to the area, sometimes from outside it as an excursion, and they spend money while visiting - more often in places away from the larger retail concerns. As part of the cultural life and identity of an area, an art trail may encourage people to move and settle there.
Adrian Stannard explored the cultural economic consequences of the planning process in more detail via the ongoing saga of the EMD Cinema and UKCG. One of his slides for this section of the talk featured a photograph from the planning committee meeting at Walthamstow Assembly Hall. The choice of that venue was his initiative. The photograph showed, chillingly and comically how the UKCG congregation had donned high visibility vests in order to make their self (corporately) known to the committee - a mass outing of construction site fluorescent yellow. What a hoot! Was it an out of order donning of a political uniform?   Hundreds of people were not able to get into the hall due to lack of space and, in answer to Adrian Stannard’s starting question, a plethora of inter-net/wireless based devices connected outside and inside establishing a contemporary form of participation.
Was this dull - a modestly proffered comment made by Adrian Stannard about the planning process at the beginning of his talk? Well, perhaps some of the slides were a bit dry, but his energy, commitment to, and knowledge of the subject outweighed this. There are, I suggest, quite a number of colourful public art works around and about the borough which could appropriately spice up the visual content of the slideshow.


Sunday, 10 July 2011

a field student of planning for unreality

Field Study’s Man in E17 has returned to something as close to the real (or is it still virtual?) world as he can get, following a particularly arduous ascent out from his navel. The navel gazing explorer lost control of his scale shifting capabilities and plummeted into the fibrous deeps of his psycho belly button. He can report it is a zone not for the faint hearted, as a variety of exotic entities reside there. Away from the omphalos and around and about in the decentring culture(s) of nowhere but E17, E11…

.
The Hitchcock Gallery - Leytonstone Tube
.

Field Study’s Man in E17 set out on the Leytonstone Arts Trail. He waited at Leytonstone Underground for the start of a guided walk and admired the Alfred Hitchcock themed mosaics adorning the entrances. The murals (The Hitchcock Gallery) are the work of Greenwich Mural Workshop. The web site outlines the scope of their public art practice. Back at Leytonstone Tube, there is a prominently displayed plaque which gives some of the social context of the mosaic murals. It reads,
‘These pictures were chosen by local people. The project was organised by the London Borough of Waltham Forest and supported by generous donations from Capital Challenge Funds, London Underground and Tesco.’
What are/were the agendas which brought these mosaics into being? What are Capital Challenge Funds and Tesco?  The pictures are there in the everyday commute; a colourful and pleasing celebration of an umbilical connection to one of the areas more eminent and accomplished offspring. At the time of unveiling the area  had experienced some seismic social and topographic shifts as a consequence of the (much contested) M11 Link Road. The demolition of a large part of the social fabric of the area was, perhaps predictably going to be followed by the projection of another more easily rendered aspect of the areas heritage. It would be interesting to find out who doesn’t know who/what Alfred Hitchcock is, and for whom the pictures are not so rooted in a heritage context. Perhaps as some sort of acknowledgment Hitchcock and Hollywood are not entirely culturally representative, Field Study’s Man recalls the unveiling included a display/show by Masquerade 2000, the locally based carnival arts organisation of national and international repute.  
Nearby, Graeme Miller’s, Linked, is a more critical and resonant exploration of the area’s past and the contemporary threads of the areas tapestry, or rather, pieces of it's mosaic.
The hazards of free open participation reared their ugly heads as a drunken bloke latched onto the walking party at the outset - the same bloke who had just reviled Field Study’s Man while the latter photographed some of the mosaics. Not for him then the pleasant sociability of an E11/E10 art walk; Field Study’s Man went in the opposite direction via the subway or art birth canal of Leytonstone Tube emerging close to ‘Time Terminus’, heading for 491 Gallery and the exciting prospect of a ‘Strange New Feeling’; a collaborative exhibition of work by artists Lily Johnson and Julia McKinlay.
It has been a long time since Field Study’s Man visited 491 Gallery on Grove Green Road and he was looking forward to seeing how the now relatively long established venue has progressed or developed. He had visited an exhibition there (c. 2001/2002) of photographs and other archival material about the building of the M11 Link Road and the galleries’ site specific connections to the road building/neighbourhood destruction. Alas, despite arriving at the gallery during the guides specified opening times, the place was not open and a strange new feeling courtesy of Johnson and Mckinlay was not to be had. Field Study’s Man recommends a visit to the virtual space of Lily Johnson’s web site nowhere but here.
Onwards in disappointment, ever in earshot of the violent rush of the nearby link road, described by the trail map as a leaden ravine, towards Norlington Road and Carne Griffiths’, Undergrowth. Field Study’s Man paused, listened and wondered if it is possible to hear the Linked voices without the listening equipment which can supposedly be accessed at Leytonstone Library. ‘Supposedly’, because, despite being advertised by Create, as an access point for the Linked listening  equipment, Leytonstone Library was not in possession of the equipment at the time of the Bookish event in May. Hopefully this inadequacy has been sorted out and anyone who heads for Leytonstone Library to get the equipment will not be disappointed.

.

Carne Griffiths, Undergrowth, work in progess, Leytonstone Arts Trail 2011
.

Carne Griffiths and his host were there and did not disappoint. Carne was in temporary residence, ink pot, pens and brushes in hand, detailing an inky up, down, in and out journey in the ‘Undergrowth’ of his imagination and observation. This was another wall piece, a mural of florally inscribed lining paper covering the entire surface of one side of the entrance hall and stairwell of an ordinary terraced house. ‘Undergrowth’, for the trail, is a work in progress, growing via an assortment of graphic techniques and treatments which Carne has developed to express a peculiar and recognisable style. Carne appeared relaxed about the scale of the drawing project, commenting the process is absorbingly therapeutic. I was interested in the presence of the written marks making up the floral forms - a sort of automatism or perhaps muscle memory according to the artist. There are obvious references to be made to William Morris’s wallpapers - this being Waltham Forest. Cinematically, I thought of, not Hitchcock, but Roman Polanski and ‘Repulsion’ and the terrible psychosis of the central character, Carole Ledoux, (Catherine Deneuvre). This is possibly a grotesque, macabre and antithetical association or projection to make given an agenda of sociability and accessibility the trail seeks to express. The home owner, to accommodate the artist, had repapered the wall and it appeared, for the duration of the cultivation of the mural, a detached flex might hang, out of reach but still visible, it’s tacks protruding like thorns - just one opportunity for the artist to temporarily arouse a spectre of the uncanny/unheimlich before such things are put back, hidden, in their proper place.


.


Some other encounters with ghostly intra and inter mural voices:




Ghost Signs off the Leytonstone High Road


.    


Field study’s Man has still to give an account of play parks and edgescapes and most importantly News from Nowhere Club’s talk via Adrian Stannard (Waltham Forest Civic Society) about how the internet might encourage the public to engage in the planning process in Waltham Forest. Some cogitation on the allotment is in order before such ……